• Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer

Philosophy at Work

think better. do better.

  • Training Workshops
  • AI Skills
  • Thinking Labs
  • Keynote Speaking
  • Case Studies
  • About
  • Resources
  • Contact

Fearless Intelligence: Courage as a tool for critical thinking

5th December 2024 By sf-admin

Fearless Intelligence: Courage as a tool for critical thinking

By Dr. Pranay Sanklecha

On February 11, 1986 , the Nobel Prize-winning physicist Richard Feynman sat in a room in Washington DC, fiddling with a pair of pliers. He was there as a member of the Rogers Commission, investigating the tragic loss of the Space Shuttle Challenger. Seven astronauts had perished when the shuttle exploded just over a minute after liftoff, and the Rogers Commission had been established by President Reagan to find out why.

During a live televised hearing, Feynman delivered one of the most memorable demonstrations in scientific history. He used his pliers – bought that morning at a local hardware store – to pull off the O-ring seal on a model of the rocket that was being passed around the Commission. Then, armed with a simple glass of ice water, he submerged a small piece of the O-ring material, explaining how cold temperatures could affect its flexibility. Pulling the material out, he compressed it, showing how it failed to return to its original shape—just as it had failed during the Challenger launch in the freezing weather.

At first glance, this looks like an example of technical failure. But engineers at Morton Thiokol, the company responsible for the O-rings, had flagged this risk. Roger Boisjoly and others raised alarms in meetings and memos, imploring decision-makers to delay the launch. But Boisjoly and the other engineers were ignored by management, who were under pressure to stick to schedule and deliver.

The management at Morton Thiokol didn’t make their mistake because of insufficient knowledge or false information. The danger had been accurately identified. But acting on the warnings would have required disrupting plans and slowing progress. It would have required “failing”, because it would have delayed the launch. It would have required taking criticism and accepting professional risk.

And all of that would have required courage.

I’m not telling this story to criticise the management of Morton Thiokol (people in glass houses etc). I’m telling it to bring out something central to good critical thinking, something which is often missed when we try to think critically or develop critical thinking in teams and organizations: critical thinking is not only an intellectual exercise. Being smart doesn’t mean you’re a good critical thinker. You also need to be brave.

Am I being over-dramatic about this? I mean, it’s just thinking, after all. Where does bravery come into it?

Well, here are five forms of courage that are essential to good critical thinking.

1.        Courage to Pause and Ask “Why?”

In the high-pressure lead-up to the Challenger launch, the engineers at Morton Thiokol tried to pause the momentum. They knew the O-ring seals might fail in cold temperatures and pushed to delay the launch. But their concerns were overridden by a relentless drive to meet deadlines and avoid disappointing NASA.

In fast-paced workplaces, asking, “Why are we doing this?” or “What assumptions are we making?” can feel like throwing a wrench into the machine. It takes courage to disrupt momentum and risk frustrating colleagues or leaders.

2.        Courage to Disagree

In the critical meeting before the Challenger launch, engineers voiced their concerns about the O-rings. They recommended postponing the launch. Yet, under pressure from NASA and Morton Thiokol’s management, their advice was dismissed. Speaking up, especially in hierarchical or high-stakes settings, takes courage, and especially so when it means disagreeing with authority figures or dominant voices in the room.

3.        Courage to Tolerate Uncertainty

According to the American novelist F. Scott Fitzgerald, “the test of a first–rate intelligence is the ability to hold two opposed ideas in the mind at the same time, and still retain the ability to function.”

I don’t know if I’d go that far. There are many ways to have a first-rate intelligence. But I am sure that being able to sit with the discomfort of not knowing is one of the keys to good critical thinking.

4.        Courage to Risk Being Wrong

Richard Feynman’s ice-water demonstration during the Rogers Commission hearings wasn’t without risk. He boldly cut through bureaucratic defensiveness, knowing he could face criticism if his demonstration fell flat. Similarly, engineers who raise concerns about decisions—like Morton Thiokol’s team—risk being wrong, and with it, their credibility or reputations.

Critical thinking requires this kind of courage: the willingness to take a stand, even when the outcomes are uncertain. Being wrong isn’t failure—it’s part of the process of learning and improving. But avoiding tough decisions or staying silent out of fear ensures that the biggest mistakes remain unchallenged.

5.        Courage to Stay Curious

Feynman’s ability to simplify and test the O-ring issue stemmed from his relentless curiosity. He refused to take vague assurances at face value, diving into the mechanics to uncover the truth. In workplaces, this same curiosity – asking “What if?” or “What else?” – can challenge complacency and lead to breakthroughs.

Yet curiosity isn’t always welcome in high-pressure or hierarchical environments. It can be dismissed as impractical or disruptive. Courage is what allows individuals to push past those norms and insist on exploring alternative paths, even when doing so challenges the status quo.

Ultimately, critical thinking requires courage because whenever we think critically we need to think for ourselves, ask our questions and assert our concerns. All this isn’t easy, but as the story of the Challenger shows, it’s incredibly important. To practice courageous critical thinking in your own context of work, here are 6 questions that you can ask to nudge yourself into thinking bravely

  1. What assumptions are driving this decision, and how can we test or challenge them?

  2. What’s the strongest counterargument to this idea, and have we fully addressed it?

  3. What’s the worst that could happen if I speak up? And what’s the worst that could happen if I don’t?

  4. If I weren’t afraid of the consequences, what would I say or do?

  5. “What don’t we know yet, and how can we proceed responsibly despite this uncertainty?”

  6. “What’s a perspective or possibility we haven’t explored yet, and why might it matter?

 

Dr. Pranay Sanklecha is a philosopher with expertise in critical thinking, meaning and purpose. Formerly Professor of philosophy at the University of Graz in Austria, Pranay holds two Masters degrees (one from Oxford and one from Bern) and a PhD in Philosophy. In addition to being a Philosophy at Work thinking partner, Pranay is the founder of The Philosophy Practice and Head Tutor for The Economist’s course on Critical Thinking. 

    More Articles

    7 Areas Where Philosophers Will be Needed

    We are now in an era of hyper-change. This is called the Great Acceleration. So what happens when things are shaking?

    Read More

    Snippets of Wisdom:
    Courage

    Quotes around the theme
    of Courage

    Read More

    Be more strategic

    Swimming upstream with strategy veteran and Salmon Labs founder, Rob Estreitinho. Dr. Brennan Jacoby and Rob discuss all things strategic thinking.

    Read More

    Filed Under: Uncategorised

    Footer

    Join our newsletter

    • Contact
    • Cookie Policy
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms and Conditions

    Copyright © 2026 · Philosophy at Work · London · Design by Supafrank