• Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer

Philosophy at Work

think better. do better.

  • Training Workshops
  • AI Skills
  • Thinking Labs
  • Keynote Speaking
  • Case Studies
  • About
  • Resources
  • Contact

8 Philosophies of Good Followership

4th September 2023 By sf-admin

8 Philosophies of Good Followership

    There is no shortage of perspectives about what it takes to be a good leader. But what about a good follower? If leaders are nothing without followers, shouldn’t we be thoughtful about what it means to be a follower? We hope the below 8 Philosophies of Good Followership make a start towards balancing the scales. 

    1.     First you must Follow (Ben Wilberforce-Ritchie) 

    Plutarch, the Ancient Greek historian, recorded many sayings from the fabled Spartans city-state. One such saying came from the Spartan King Agesilaus II, and was translated roughly as: “One must learn to follow, before one can lead”. What resonates most from this simple phrase is an appreciation of mutual understanding, leader to follower. 

    In business, leaders can fail to succeed for a multitude of reasons, but failing to inspire those around them has to come close to the top of the list. Time and time again I’ve seen projects fail because leaders don’t appreciate their team’s perspective, and this is the pitfall that Agesilaus is warning against. 

    Spend time as a member of the team, and you’ll swiftly get to know what the team needs from a leader. Only then will you know to address these needs when handed the baton of accountability.

    1.     What It Means to Be a Good Follower in a World Focused on Leaders (Dr Naeema Pasha) 

    Robert Kelley, who began studying followership a generation ago, says: “Being a good follower means thinking for yourself” 

    We often hear about the importance of leadership in the workplace, but what about followership – because the leadership and followership must be in symbiosis for things to happen well. Kelley talks about thinking for yourself and one meaning from this stance is that a follower must use their own good judgement and their own intuition and values, in order to follow in a way that is committed to themselves and to the overall role and goal. 

    As such, being a good follower according to Kelley isn’t at all about passivity or blind obedience. Rather it means being able to follow a leader’s direction while also following one’s own conscience. Of course, there will be times this causes confusion and conflict. The importance of ‘thinking for oneself’ becomes even more critical at such times. In these moments, being a follower requires the quality of courage to be able to speak, question and answer. The ability to stand up for and stand up to their leader when needed is a crucial part of good followership. Being able to speak truth to power is a huge responsibility within followership requiring both courage and humility. 

    1.     Aiming for fewer corporate Philanthropists (Ben Wilberforce-Ritchie) 

    Robert Tressel’s fantastic book The Ragged Trousered Philanthropist is based on the premise that every employee who is not the owner, senior leader, or shareholder of a company is a philanthropist. 

    How? 

    Because philanthropy is the practice of sacrificing one’s time or money for the welfare of others, and employees on lower salaries sacrifice their time five or six days a week to support the financial welfare of the owners and shareholders of their companies. This could become a rather bleak picture of society, unless we reframe it as something to be aware of and protect against, by remembering what it is like to be a follower. 

    So, when you’re making business decisions that weigh up company profit and shareholder returns against employee salaries, benefits, and welfare, just consider the number of corporate philanthropists in your organisation. Really, the fewer you have, the better you’re doing. 

    1.     Transformational Followership (Dr Brennan Jacoby)

    You don’t get leaders without followers. Like the concepts of ‘light’ and ‘shade’, ‘up’ and ‘down’, or ‘heavy’ and ‘light’, the meaning of what it is to lead is relative to the essence of followership. To be a good leader is, therefore, interwoven with what it means to follow well. 

    The dance of leadership and followership is expressed in the ‘transformational’ theory of leadership, which holds that good leaders operate in ways that elevate the maturity and ideals of followers. But if leadership and followership are inextricably linked, then the reverse should also be expected: 

    We should aspire to what transformational followership. 

    Transformational followership would entail following in ways that elevate a leader’s maturity and ideals through constructive challenge and holding them to account. Suddenly, from this angle, followership has just as critical a role to play in the culture and success of an organisation as leadership. 

    Through this lens, responsibility is shared between leaders and followers. From this perspective, there’s nowhere to ‘pass the buck’. 

    1.     The hidden power of followers (Dr Skye C. Cleary)

    While leadership is often associated with power, German philosopher Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel showed how followers have more power than they think. In his 1807 book The Phenomenology of Spirit, Hegel explains that understanding ourselves through the perspective of others is critically important for self-awareness. The acknowledgement of others is so fundamental that Hegel says, “Self-consciousness exists in and for itself when, and by the fact that, it so exists for another; that is to say, it exists only in being acknowledged.”  In other words, we become self-conscious only when other people acknowledge us. 

    One application of this to the workplace is that leaders only have power when followers acknowledge them. It’s clear that in order to assume a leadership position, leaders need followers. But it’s more than that: followers affirm leaders as leaders. In fact, leaders’ identities rest on followers acknowledging them. And ultimately, leaders’ power rests with their followers too. A productive relationship can only develop when leader and follower mutually recognize one another – otherwise they’re bound to lose themselves in power struggles, stagnate in tyranny, or destroy the relationship entirely. Hegel writes, “Action by one side only would be useless because what is to happen can only be brought about by both.” To create a flourishing and constructive relationship, both leaders and followers need to rise above conflicts, recognize one another’s roles as essential to their mutual goals, and commit to working together as one organ in a living unity.  

    1.     Be a follower, but beware following the crowd! (Ben Wilberforce-Ritchie) 

    Victor Frankl, the 20th Century Austrian Psychologist and holocaust survivor, warned about humanity’s ‘existential vacuum’. He believed that humans have lost their basic animal instincts due to cognitive development, yet faced the challenge of still needing to make decisions. Without this instinct, he argued, humans turned to conformism (doing what other people do) or totalitarianism (doing what other people want you to do). Both are bad, in his view, as they represent boredom on the part of the individual, as they would rather have others think for them than think for themselves. This is indeed a challenge, as companies cannot thrive with bored employees. 

    The solution? 

    Frankl advised that we motivate our ‘will to meaning’ from its state of languid immobility. In effect, if you want to motivate your employees, encourage them to act, experience, encounter or reflect to get them to follow their own paths rather than that of the crowd. 

    1.     No one should eat last (Dr Brennan Jacoby)

    Far from being a deadly sin, the 20th century philosopher, Ayn Rand, championed pride. 

    For Rand, being proud meant, rejecting any doctrine that preaches self-sacrifice as a moral virtue. It’s an understatement to say that she would have not supported the contemporary version of servant leadership claiming that leaders should ‘eat last’. 

    But then, neither would she have liked the idea of followers eating last. 

    For Rand, altruism of all sorts was corrupt because of its inconsistency with freedom and individual rights. Presumably her dietary advice would be that leaders (and followers) should simply eat when they want to. But while other philosophers, for example Nietzsche, disparaged followership all together, Rand’s thinking leaves room for what we might call ‘selfish followership’ – following because you want to. 

    A selfish follower can be proud. They can reject the idea of following a leader out of duty, and forgo altruism insofar as they are not being a follower for the sake of anyone else but themselves. To minds that have inherited an ethic of altruism, and a vision of professionalism that values solidarity, selfish followership might seem unpalatable. But Rand argued that selfishness was the only rational way to live. 

    Now, pause and consider employee engagement in the post-covid era: In this landscape, where employee (dis)engagement is sometimes framed as ‘disloyalty’ or even ‘apathy’, Rand’s understanding of selfishness as a virtue might just provide helpful food for thought.

    1.     Serve to Lead (Ben Wilberforce-Ritchie) 

    ‘Serve to Lead’, this is the memorable motto of Sandhurst, one of the most famous leadership academies in the world. It is here that every British Army Officer has been trained since 1947, using tried and tested methods dating back to 1741. I like to think they know a thing or two about leadership. How intriguing, then, that their motto supports a vision of bottom up, rather than top down, leadership. 

    In businesses today, we regularly hear the phrase “flat structure” used to counteract the assumption that strict management hierarchies exist. However, let’s be realistic, management hierarchies definitely do exist, no matter how horizontal we claim our organisational structures to be. 

    In the military, there is a clear command and control structure, but that doesn’t mean leaders cannot serve those they manage. Perhaps we would benefit from separating ‘management’ from ‘leadership’ and, learning from Sandhurst’s example, encourage everyone who wishes to be a manager to focus first on serving those they desire to lead. 

    For more food for thought on the theme of good followership work, digest the ‘Snippets of Wisdom’ about followership here.

    More Articles

    7 Areas Where Philosophers Will be Needed

    We are now in an era of hyper-change. This is called the Great Acceleration. So what happens when things are shaking?

    Read More

    Snippets of Wisdom:
    Courage

    Quotes around the theme
    of Courage

    Read More

    Power People
    and Process

    In conversation with Jess Majekodunmi and Dan Kiernan about the intersection of AI and work

    Read More

    Filed Under: Uncategorised

    Footer

    Join our newsletter

    • Contact
    • Cookie Policy
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms and Conditions

    Copyright © 2026 · Philosophy at Work · London · Design by Supafrank