• Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer

Philosophy at Work

think better. do better.

  • Training Workshops
  • AI Skills
  • Thinking Labs
  • Keynote Speaking
  • Case Studies
  • About
  • Resources
  • Contact

The Özil Effect: rethinking productivity at work

23rd September 2024 By sf-admin

The Özil Effect: rethinking productivity at work

By Steven Campbell-Harris

Mesut Özil’s career was, by any objective standard, a remarkable success. A World Cup winner with Germany, he stood out as a preeminent footballer of his generation, widely celebrated for his knack in creating goal scoring opportunities for his teammates. 

And yet, despite these undeniable feats, Özil’s performances often provoked fierce criticism. His naturally languid running style, and seemingly disinterested demeanour, often drew accusations he wasn’t giving his all. To fans, he just didn’t look like a team player. 

Interestingly, this treatment of football players mirrors our assessment of performance in today’s workplace – a phenomenon we might call ‘The Özil effect’. We often notice, and reward, conduct that looks like work more than the work itself. Similarly, we withhold rewards when colleagues don’t really look like they’re working. 

A friend of mine was recently called out in a performance review for appearing ‘relaxed’ around the office. When he asked what he could do to improve his work, he was told there wasn’t a problem. His work was superb, and always done on time. ‘Isn’t my looking relaxed just perception then?’ he said. ‘Ah, but perception is reality,’ his manager coolly replied.  

The manager’s response reflects the popular idea that how someone is perceived at work is- in many respects – as important as the tangible results they produce. 

And yet, there really is a difference between perception and reality. 

There is a difference between looking like you are contributing and really contributing. 

There is actually a difference between output and appearance. 

Just as we perfected the art of gazing intently at our teachers in school to create the illusion of rapt attention, we have honed the craft of appearing absorbed at work, even when we aren’t. We tell our colleagues that we are busier than we are, walk a half step quicker around our boss, and stay late to be seen to do so. 

All this performing creates problems; it makes performance management more prone to bias, and it takes up vital energy and attention that could be put to better use. What’s more, it exerts a subtle pressure on the tasks that make up our day. Meetings, responding to emails, and calls all look like work, so we tend to do more of them. Thinking doesn’t seem like work, so we end up doing less of it. As a former colleague of mine poignantly put it, ‘I don’t want to be caught thinking at the office.’

This is absurd.

Taking a moment to gaze out the window in the middle of the workday may not improve the perception we’re on task, but it may be just what we need to find a different perspective on our problem. Better that than sitting at our desk mindlessly typing away. Yet the demands of a perception-based performance culture can force us to highlight the appearance of work over genuine productivity. Our output, and our companies, end up paying the price. 

So why do we persevere with this limiting idea? It all seems to stem from an outdated view of what work is. 

Myth 1: Physical Activity Equals Productivity 

We often assume that people are most productive when they are physically engaged in some task. Motion means action, and action means work. While this might hold true on the factory floor, it doesn’t apply if we are immersed in what management theorist Peter Drucker called ‘knowledge work’; the manipulation of information and specialised knowledge. In knowledge work, tasks that are central to our success – like problem solving and creative thinking – can’t often be directly seen. 

Myth 2: All Work Produces Linear Returns

We tend to believe that the more time and effort we put into our work, the greater our output will be. While this might hold true on the factory line, where each movement produces the same result, it falls apart when applied to knowledge work. Thinking – a central component of knowledge work – yields variable and nonlinear returns. Hours of reflecting on a problem might produce minimal results, yet a brilliant new plan can strike in an instant. It’s no wonder that we hesitate to schedule time to think. It might be a waste of time. 

And yet, it’s far better to waste some of our time than all of it. As the author Michael Lewis rightly noted, ‘Some people waste years of their lives not being willing to waste hours of their lives.’ Taking time to think may lead to wasted hours, but it will be more than made up for in new breakthroughs and innovations. 

In recent years, the shift to remote work has offered an opportunity to depart from this ‘perception is reality’ culture. 

Freed from the pressure to constantly perform and appear busy, we have the chance to  channel our energy into tasks that truly make a difference. With greater flexibility, we can design our workdays to align with our natural productivity rhythms. Staring out the window, taking a longer lunch break, or going for a walk can be seen not as diversions, but vital moments of rest and reflection. Instead of being judged on appearance, we can be judged on results. The Özils of the office – often misunderstood or undervalued – may yet thrive. 

 

Steven Campbell-Harris is a philosophy educator, teacher trainer, writer and Philosophy at Work thinking partner with a passion for bringing the benefits of philosophy to a wider audience. He currently teaches Philosophy at the London Academy of Excellence and is also a Senior Specialist and Teacher Trainer at The Philosophy Foundation. 

    More Articles

    Slow Thinking Tools

    A 4-step process to be used with your little yellow journal

    Read More

    Power People
    and Process

    In conversation with Jess Majekodunmi and Dan Kiernan about the intersection of AI and work

    Read More

    7 Areas Where Philosophers Will be Needed

    We are now in an era of hyper-change. This is called the Great Acceleration. So what happens when things are shaking?

    Read More

    Filed Under: Uncategorised

    Footer

    Join our newsletter

    • Contact
    • Cookie Policy
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms and Conditions

    Copyright © 2026 · Philosophy at Work · London · Design by Supafrank