
Should work satisfy?
Authors: Dr. Naeema Pasha and Dr. Brennan Jacoby
Should we expect our work to satisfy us?
When we asked our network that question, 93% of those who responded said ‘yes’, we should expect our work to be satisfying.
This got us thinking.
After all, satisfaction – real satisfaction – is hard to come by. As our colleague Ben Wilberforce-Ritchie shared in his article on the philosophy of satisfaction (which you can read here), Antoine De Saint-Exupery highlighted humanity’s limitations around satisfaction. Here’s how Saint-Exupery put it: “the people where you live… grow five thousand roses in the same garden… and they do not find what they are looking for”. The ancient greek thinker, Plato, went even further, He elevated dissatisfaction to nothing short of a virtue, saying “the man who is ready to taste every branch of learning, is glad to learn and never satisfied”.
Surely it would be odd to advocate for work that is unsatisfying. The 93% who said that work should be satisfying seem correct. But are they really being realistic?
We wondered.
And we thought that maybe something else was going on. Perhaps, when our colleagues and friends say that we should expect work to be satisfying they mean that it should enrich their lives, even if it doesn’t fully satisfy all their wants and needs.
So we asked a second question: “Is satisfying work the same as meaningful work?” This time 47% said yes, while 53% said no.
Not exactly conclusive results.
Perhaps, in the end, when we all talk about employee satisfaction, workplace satisfaction, and meaningful work, what we really care about is that we’re doing work that is good.
“…an increasing number of people are looking for something even deeper.”
After all, the literature about the relationship between work and psychology throughout history suggests that our experience and expectations of work have changed over the decades. Work has gone from being something we did to pay bills and fulfill a duty, to then being something that many people believe should provide them with a sense of satisfaction also – which our survey supported in its findings.
But as we know, societal values don’t stay the same, and there is evidence to suggest that an increasing number of people will want more than satisfaction, that they are looking for something even deeper. We see that many reports in this field show that as well as satisfaction, workers may also want work to offer them meaningfulness too.
So, we thought some more.
And then we asked our networks what they thought was most important for making work good. The responses were very interesting. 14% said that the aims of the work mattered most. 18% answered that choice in how they worked was key. But the two top answers were ‘impact – on others & the world’ (35%) and ‘relationships – i.e. the people’ (33%).
This is interesting, and it makes complete sense. Throughout the history of work, in times of crisis the desire for work to be more meaningful has increased. If life is sweet, you’re less likely to reflect on the goodness or importance of your work. But if a trauma (e.g. Global Financial Crash, Brexit, Covid, near death experience) disrupts your day to day, you are more likely to pause and weigh up what you are doing with your life. If you are aware that you only have so many weeks left to work, you might as well be doing something good and meaningful.
We are living and working in uncertain times, and we are often reminded that the ancient philosopher, Heraclitus, might just have been correct when he said that ‘change is the only constant in life’. In this context, it would make sense that, for many of us, ‘relationships’ and ‘impact’ would rise to the top as some of the most important parts of the work we do.
Having thought through the responses of our colleagues and friends about satisfying and meaningful work, we are hopeful. Hopeful because as so many businesses grapple with making their businesses places that people want to work, deep and meaningful conversations will be had. What might start as a chat about employee satisfaction with hybrid work arrangements, will hopefully raise important matters concerning the good impact that employees and employers alike want to have on the world.
What we’ve learned about satisfaction is that it’s not just about whether or not an employee is happy enough with their work arrangements. It’s an opportunity to assess, and reassess, the good products and services that can really make a difference when a group of thoughtful people work together.
There’s a lot going on under the surface of satisfaction, and we hope the above thoughts have given you some good food for thought too.
We’d suggest bringing the following questions into conversations when discussions about satisfaction begin:
- What do we mean by satisfaction in our own context?
- What are the core ingredients for satisfying work?
- If you knew you only had a short time left to work, would you change anything to make your work more meaningful?
If you’d like to discuss any of the themes raised in this article, start a conversation with Philosophy at Work here.
More Articles

Power People
and Process
In conversation with Jess Majekodunmi and Dan Kiernan about the intersection of AI and work

Slow thinking with Tom Freeman
In an age of ever-faster tech iterations, what might we gain from practicing slow thinking? In this conversation with Philosophy at Work, Headspace’s Tom Freeman explores tech, wellbeing and intentionality


